UltimateDisney.com | DVD Reviews | DVDizzy.com: DVD & Blu-ray Release Schedule | Search This Site
Scrubs on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 • Season 7
"Scrubs" The Complete Fifth Season DVD Review
Of the thirty-four primetime network television shows that debuted in the fall of 2001, "Scrubs" was one of just ten programs (a mere four of them comedies) to remain in production in the 2005-06 season. Clearly, the medical comedy was doing something right, a claim that was supported by the record four Emmy nominations the series received in 2005. As with most TV industry decisions, the unusual fate of "Scrubs" was determined, at least largely, by viewership ratings. Though widely praised as a unique take on comedy, many argued that NBC's treatment of "Scrubs" was uniquely unflattering. Some people -- including cast/crew members and series creator Bill Lawrence -- have reasonably contended that the opposite forces behind the show (Disney's Touchstone Television produces, while NBC Universal airs) account for the limited promotion and occasional schedule change. Common sense supports that NBC would see greater value in marketing its in-house productions like "The Apprentice", "Fear Factor", and the various "Law & Order" series than shows which will only yield short-term profit for NBC as a distributor. Still, this argument ignores the fact that, even in the recent years that enforced studio/network alliances, some of NBC's biggest and most supported hits ("Friends", "ER") have been shows produced by other parties.
In truth, "Scrubs" had not been among the most-watched primetime series for a few years. At the same time, while modest in size, "Scrubs"' audience was large in its dedication. Viewers stuck with the show they considered television's best secret through night changes and time changes. They helped make the May 2005 DVD release of "Scrubs"' Complete First Season an enduring strong seller. And they, especially those in the all-important 18-49-year-old demographic, justified the show being renewed once again.
The faithful "Scrubs" following was rewarded when NBC began airing the show's fifth season halfway into the '05-'06 season. Beginning with the season premiere, on 2006's first Tuesday, viewers were treated to a full hour of "Scrubs" via back-to-back new episodes. Perhaps because they felt "very dissed" (as Zach Braff put it) and perhaps because no one was seeing the episodes still being churned out on a regular schedule, those behind "Scrubs" seemed to shift in Season 5 from pleasing viewers to merely pleasing themselves. While that sounds like a recipe for disaster, it wasn't. Critics stayed behind the show, and viewership levels remained steadfast even in the face of tough competition. In Season 5, "Scrubs" definitely ups the ante for wackiness, but it does so while remaining faithful to its central cast of characters and while still managing to squeeze some heart and drama into the proceedings.
The three fresh-faced interns of Sacred Heart Hospital who were the focus of the show upon launch have long since matured but still face plenty of life obstacles on- and off-duty. J.D. (Zach Braff) remains a goofy narrator and lead who cares for his patients but rarely lets them hinder his penchant for fun. This season gives him a pair of new love interests (Mandy Moore appearing in two episodes that perhaps reflect her concurrent real-life relationship with Braff and Elizabeth Banks as an end-of-the-season cliffhanger-supplier), a new mode of transportation (a blue scooter named Sasha), and two new homes (initially rooming with repeat ex Elliot, then buying a half-acre of land upon which merely an elderly gay-attracting deck is built). J.D.'s extremely close best friend Turk (Donald Faison) competes to advance his career as a surgeon, though his young marriage with sassy nurse Carla (Judy Reyes) stays in the foreground, as they try to have a baby. Elliot (Sarah Chalke) begins the season as part of a fellowship outside of home base, but the show gets her back to Sacred Heart hospital as quickly as possible. There, as her neuroses provide a steady stream of laughter, she gets another new love interest in barely-defined intern Keith (Travis Schuldt). Though the relationship begins most casually, it develops into something more and contributes to J.D.'s dislike of Keith.
While the show intends otherwise and many will disagree, the two constant figures of authority -- narcissistic-yet-self-loathing attending Dr. Cox (John C. McGinley) and detached chief of medicine Dr. Kelso (Ken Jenkins) -- move further into territories of unsympathetic and sympathetic, respectively. Cox's hard-edged speechifying shtick feels old hat and snatches time away from more interesting elements, without quite qualifying as a detriment. On the other hand, the grouchy Kelso is quite the hoot, his old-fashioned ways, prejudices, and intermittent air of befuddlement making him a regular source of hilarity. Though he's often supposed to be the "bad guy", you can't help but like Kelso and appreciate how removed he is from his doctors. Of the two, however, Cox features far more prominently, and he is given a dramatic arc this season after an ill-fated judgment call throws him for a loop. Kelso's wacky extra-hospital life is repeatedly referenced (his family supposedly includes an obese, paralyzed wife and a play-writing gay son) but never seen, while Cox's unmarried arrangement with the usually-caustic Jordan (Christa Miller) and young son Jack (Andrew Miller) stays on the radar.
Many of "Scrubs"' most hilarious moments feature supporting characters, a group which only grows this season. Though figuring in every episode and even narrating one, the unnamed Janitor (Neil Flynn) somewhat still feels like the president of this class. His days of making trouble for J.D. are far from over, but he has expanded his repertoire to also torment Kelso, Cox, and Carla as well. From time to time, the Janitor's antics occasionally step over a line of good taste, as "Scrubs" has occasionally done from its launch.
Like never before, Season 5 dabbles in the bizarre, as things that might make sense in one of the show's many fantasy/dream asides appear to actually be happening. It's easy to take this in stride as the various shenanigans keep us laughing as intended. But scenes and storylines involving J.D. contorted into a backpack, a beach on the hospital's roof, and the Janitor inexplicably robbing an Asian couple are bound to leave thoughtful viewers scratching their heads. Surely, such random hilarity would never have been genuinely incorporated into the show in its early, more sincere Season 1 episodes. The better off-the-wall moments of Season 5 are framed as unreal fantasies; some of the most memorable images of this type pertain to J.D.'s dream of Floating Head Doctor and his vampire screenplay/movie Dr. Acula. Other highlights include Turk going on an Indiana Jones-type exploratory surgery, PSA-type gags about child-smothering and coffee addiction, Carla's glass-shattering response to a Janitor comment, and J.D. considering his adoption options at a grandfather kennel.
Getting back to those supporting characters, they once again include such likable misfits as "The Todd" (Robert Maschio), the fratboyish surgeon to whom sexual innuendos never get old; Ted (Sam Lloyd), the hospital's pitiful, put-upon lawyer (whose a capella band, The Worthless Peons, again harmonizes to nice effect); Laverne (Aloma Wright) the gossipy veteran nurse; and Doug (Johnny Kastl), a hapless morgue doctor. Joining them are J.D.'s quirky interns, who range from the old to the hairy and generate laughs by their presence, ineptitude, and willingness to appease their superior.
Though silliness is rampant throughout the season to the point where new viewers may be stumped at trying to figure out what's real and what isn't, "Scrubs" still attempts, The Complete Fifth Season of "Scrubs" serves up the 2006 season's 24 episodes on three discs. It is timed to arrive right after the sixth season finale, which airs this Thursday on NBC. Earlier this week, it was announced that "Scrubs" would return to NBC this fall for a seventh and final season. Assuming Buena Vista keeps the show on the same schedule it has for the past two years, one can expect the Sixth Season DVD to arrive in the fall and the Seventh Season to complete the series' run shortly after the series finale airs next spring.
Episode synopses follow, with a star ( Disc 1
2. My Rite of Passage (21:40) (Originally aired January 3, 2006)
3. My Day at the Races (21:41) (Originally aired January 10, 2006)
5. My New God (21:42) (Originally aired January 17, 2006)
8. My Big Bird (21:11) (Originally aired January 24, 2006)
Disc 2
11. My Buddy's Booty (21:42) (Originally aired February 28, 2006)
12. My Cabbage (21:41) (Originally aired February 28, 2006)
13. My Five Stages (21:41) (Originally aired March 7, 2006)
14. My Own Personal Hell (21:41) (Originally aired March 14, 2006)
15. My Extra Mile (21:39) (Originally aired March 21, 2006)
17. My Chopped Liver (21:41) (Originally aired April 4, 2006)
18. My New Suit (21:43) (Originally aired April 11, 2006)
|
UltimateDisney.com | DVD Reviews | DVDizzy.com: DVD & Blu-ray Release Schedule | Search This Site
Scrubs on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 • Season 7
Page 1: Show and Season 5 Discussion, Disc 1, and Disc 2
|
Reviewed May 17, 2007.