UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search UltimateDisney.com
Scrubs on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 NEW!
"Scrubs" The Complete Fifth Season DVD Review
Disc 3
19. His Story III (21:49) (Originally aired April 18, 2006)
21. My Fallen Idol (21:30) (Originally aired May 2, 2006)
23. My Urologist (21:41) (Originally aired May 16, 2006)
VIDEO and AUDIO
All the episodes of "Scrubs" are presented in 1.33:1 fullscreen. Though the season finale did air in high-definition 16x9 as a test, it was apparently deemed unsuccessful, as "Scrubs" remained one of the few network series to not air in HD this current season. Sound-wise, "Scrubs" once again serves up a Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack. It's appropriate and relatively lively for what is today considered a sitcom. Compared to syndicated reairings and the original broadcasts that I saw on merely a stereo television, the leap to 5.1 is definitely noticeable. The mixes provide a more satisfying range, a distinct depth, and more "oomph" to the usual palette of whimsical narration, fast and funny dialogue, occasional bickering, rare sound effect, and closing montage independent rock selection. For the first time in Region 1, a French language track is also offered for the show, in Dolby Surround.
BONUS FEATURES
Three episodes are offered with optional audio commentaries. The third and final commentary is on another bonus altogether. It is an extended cut (29:17) of "My Way Home", the series' Zach Braff-directed 100th episode. What is perhaps the season's best episode gets even better with alternate edits and several extensions. As usual, the show benefits from having a little more runtime than its usual 20 minutes plus credits. The additions are numerous and include some funny moments. This extended cut, which is presented in Dolby Surround, is also provided with an audio commentary by Braff. He speaks very much with a director's perspective, identifying various technical and dramatic challenges, pointing out differences between this cut he submitted and the trimmed version that aired, and highlighting little aspects that might otherwise be overlooked. It's clear that he's very passionate about the show, the episode, and directing in general. As such, though solo and uncharacteristically serious, this track is a real treat.
The lone featurette, "My 117 Episodes: 5 Seasons of Scrubs" is a 17-minute look at how the show has developed over the years. There are lots of short clips from over the five years, which offer neat comprehensive perspective and are accompanied by comments from cast and crew. Much attention is given to the 100th episode, a celebration for which is the source of some talent interview clips. While not outstanding, this is a fairly entertaining and succinct retrospective of the first five seasons. Something longer and more detailed would be better suited to the seventh/final season box, but this is still one of the series' longest and best general documentary bonuses.
Next, seven deleted scenes are presented. Running just over 8 minutes altogether, these brief excisions/alternate cuts of existing scenes are set-up with a look at where they'd fit into the relevant episode.
Rounding out the set, Alternate Lines are offered on 19 different sequences, which the menu identifies by episode and key phrase. Each segment opens with the final version as seen on air, followed by a variety of alternate takes that illustrate cast members' ability to improvise and occasional difficulty in fighting laughter. Disc 1's Main Menu holds two Easter Eggs. For directions on accessing them, consult our Guide to DVD Easter Eggs. As for their contents, they are as Easter Eggs should be -- short, silly clips that are neat to see, but no great loss if you don't find them.
Outside of the "My Big Bird" commentary and Easter Eggs, all bonuses can be found on Disc 3. In a nice and rare touch, they're all subtitled, even the commentaries and brief Easter Eggs. An animated episode which was mentioned in promos for this DVD release is nowhere to be found.
Disc One opens with previews for Ratatouille, "Kyle XY": The Complete First Season, and "Home Improvement": The Complete Sixth Season. No additional promos are included.
MENUS, PACKAGING and DESIGN
This season's menus abandon the animated hospital tour motif of past DVD sets. Instead, each Main Menu opts for a simple fullscreen clip montage with occasional transitional effect, set of course to the full cut of Lazlo Bane's theme tune "Superman."
Packaging, if a little less inspired, is still consistent. The front cover offers, once again, a composite group photo of questionable worth. Inside, more standard and strange set-ups of J.D., Carla, Turk, and Elliot form the front and back covers of the six-sided Digipak. An episodes/extras list is found, the three discs share two sides (requiring two to overlap), and the spot for an insert holds only a booklet promoting other Disney TV shows on DVD. The final side offers more pictures, including snapshots of some of Season 5's guest stars.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
A lot of the time, charting the artistic success of a television show merits a bell curve. "Scrubs" seems destined to end a year from now after seven seasons. That feels appropriate and points to this often hilarious medical comedy as joining the majority of shows that reach their creative apex in the middle -- where characters have been sufficiently developed and writers aren't yet struggling to avoid repetition. Fortunately, "Scrubs"' curve has a gentle slope.
The Complete Fifth Season finds Touchstone's rather brilliant series just a small step below its best. By now, its 3-plot structure is plenty apparent and the demands of U.S. network television (lots of episodes, but short enough to allow for about a third of airtime to go to commercials) do manage to stifle the show slightly. Still, Season 5 emerges as another clear, consistent success for "Scrubs." It goes a little heavy on random silliness and the multi-episode dramatic plotlines don't always gel with their surroundings or resonate as much as they hope to. But these are minor complaints next to the huge doses of laughter and smarts that easily establish the show as one of television's best. "Scrubs" may continue to draw ratings in the mid-single-digit range and I'm sure that those who haven't caught up on the show's past are probably a little lost trying to jump in now. But these facts just make the millions who "get" this show and appreciate its sense of humor feel all the more privileged.
Buena Vista's three-disc set is another easy one to recommend. It may not be quite as loaded with extras as previous seasons (which is strange since it's the first season to enter production since "Scrubs" started turning up on DVD), but its three commentaries, extended episode, unused footage, and featurette are enough to satisfy fans of the show. Of course, even now that "Scrubs" is easy to find in syndication, the DVD's presentation easily surpasses reruns (especially Comedy Central's) with network-bug-free, at-your-own-pace, better-picture-and-sound viewing undoubtedly justifying the reasonable asking price. Just as long as you already have Seasons 1-4 of "Scrubs", do not hesitate adding Season 5 to your collection.
|
Scrubs on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 NEW!
Related Reviews:
Scrubs: The Complete Fourth Season (2004-05) • Scrubs: The Complete Third Season (2003-04)
Scrubs: The Complete Second Season (2002-03) • Scrubs: The Complete First Season (2001-02)
Home Improvement: The Complete Sixth Season (1996-97) • Dinosaurs: The Complete Third and Fourth Seasons (1992-94)
Ellen: The Complete Season 4 (1996-97) • Desperate Housewives: The Complete Second Season (2005-06)
The Golden Girls: The Complete Fifth Season (1989-90) • Home Improvement: Season 5 (1995-96) • Boy Meets World: Season 3 (1995-96)
Invincible (2006) • Remember the Titans: Director's Cut (2000) • Chicken Little (2005) • Balloon Farm (1999)
The Princess Diaries (2001) • Herbie: Fully Loaded (2005) • Brother Bear 2 (2006) • Felicity: Senior Year DVD Collection (2001-02)
Night at the Museum: 2-Disc Special Edition (2006) • The Shaggy Dog (2006) • Dreamgirls: 2-Disc Showstopper Edition (2006)
Page 1: Show and Season 5 Discussion, Disc 1, and Disc 2
|
Reviewed May 17, 2007.